A Legend Born on the Lake: The Silver Lake Sea Serpent
Silver Lake has a secret that goes back over 150 years — and it's one of the most delightful tales in all of Western New York.
In 1855, Artemus B. Walker, owner of the local Walker Hotel, hatched an ingenious plan to draw visitors to the area. Drawing inspiration from Seneca Nation stories of a large dragon-like creature said to have once inhabited Silver Lake, he and a group of friends secretly constructed an elaborate sea serpent from wire, painted canvas, and bellows. On moonlit evenings, they floated their creation across the lake, using the bellows and attached hoses to make the beast dramatically rise and fall in the water — terrifying fishermen and locals alike.
The ruse worked brilliantly. Word spread fast, and curious visitors flocked to Silver Lake hoping to catch a glimpse of the mysterious creature. The hoax held for two years, until 1857, when a fire destroyed the Walker Hotel — and the charred remains of the "monster" were discovered among the ruins.
But rather than fade into embarrassment, the story became a beloved piece of local identity. Throughout the hamlet, you'll find stunning sea serpent art installations created by local artists in wood and metal — a permanent, whimsical tribute to the creature that put Silver Lake on the map. The legend lives on, fondly remembered and celebrated by the community to this day.
Get your own piece of local history! Browse our collection of merchandise featuring the beloved Silver Lake Sea Serpent — and wear the legend wherever you go. Shop Now →